1 Psychology and human development1.9 Emotion

1.9 Emotion

2 min read2 figures

Written by Resident Doctor Committee · Published

Components of an emotional response

An emotion coordinates appraisal, subjective feeling, autonomic and endocrine arousal, expression and an action tendency such as escape or attack. The components can diverge, as when a person avoids a situation with a racing heart but reports no anxiety.

Body-first and parallel theories

Theory

Order of events

What the felt emotion is

James-Lange

Stimulus, then visceral and skeletal change, then feeling

The perception of that bodily change

Cannon-Bard

Feeling and bodily arousal arise together and independently

A thalamic signal to the cortex, sent in parallel with a signal to the body

  • Under James-Lange, a person feels afraid because they tremble, so palpitations that come before conscious fear in panic fit the theory.

  • Cannon argued that visceral change is too slow and too non-specific to tell one emotion from another.

Two-factor theory

  • Schachter-Singer theory holds that emotion is general physiological arousal plus a cognitive label for its cause, taken from the situation.

  • In their 1962 experiment, uninformed volunteers given adrenaline reported emotion that followed a confederate's mood, but informed volunteers, who could blame the injection, felt little.

Appraisal and affective primacy

  • Lazarus's cognitive appraisal theory holds that appraisal always comes first, and the emotion and arousal follow from it.

  • Primary appraisal judges whether the event matters to wellbeing; secondary appraisal judges whether one can cope.

  • The emotion changes when the person reappraises the event, which supports cognitive therapy.

Schachter and Singer put arousal before the label, whereas Lazarus puts appraisal before both emotion and arousal.

Follow the arrows in each row: James-Lange puts bodily change before the feeling, Cannon-Bard sends feeling and arousal out in parallel from the thalamus, Schachter-Singer puts arousal before the label, and Lazarus puts appraisal before both emotion and arousal. Drawn for MRCPsychiatrist
  • Zajonc's affective primacy hypothesis holds that feeling can arise before and apart from cognition.

  • Zajonc based it on the mere exposure effect: people come to prefer shapes they cannot recognise having seen.

  • Damasio's somatic marker hypothesis holds that learned bodily responses, felt as gut reactions, bias a decision before reasoning is complete.

  • Its core evidence is the absent anticipatory skin conductance response on the Iowa Gambling Task.

Basic emotions

Model

Primary emotions

Further detail

Ekman

Six universal: happiness, sadness, fear, anger, surprise, disgust

Each has a facial expression recognised across cultures

Plutchik (psychoevolutionary)

Eight, in four opposing pairs

Secondary emotions blend two primaries, such as love (joy plus acceptance) and contempt

Panksepp

Seven subcortical systems of the mammalian brain

SEEKING, RAGE, FEAR, LUST, CARE, PANIC/GRIEF and PLAY

Ekman, Levenson and Friesen found that basic emotions differ in their physiology.

  • Anger raises both heart rate and finger temperature.

  • Fear raises heart rate but leaves the fingers cool.

  • Disgust lowers skin temperature.

The limbic system

  • Paul MacLean coined the term limbic system in 1952 and later proposed the triune brain.

  • His main anatomical addition to the circuit was the amygdala, together with the septal area.

Arousal and performance

  • The Yerkes-Dodson relationship between arousal and performance is an inverted U.

  • The optimum arousal is lower for complex or new tasks and higher for simple, rehearsed ones.

Compare the two curves: performance on the difficult task peaks at moderate arousal and then falls, while performance on the simple task keeps rising to much higher arousal, so the optimum is lower for complex tasks. Yerkes and Dodson 1908, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons